Skip to main content

Independent Publishing – Pros & Cons

Independent Publishing – Pros & ConsIndependent Publishing essentially has two definitions. In the commercial publishing world, independent publishers (also called “indies” or “small presses”) are small publishers that publish a limited number of books per year (usually less than 10). Their status may also be determined by an annual sales figure (i.e. less than $50 million, after returns and discounts).  Small presses operate independently of any large conglomerates or multi-national corporations, and make up approximately half the market share of the book publishing industry. Often they focus on specific genres and niche markets.

The other definition of independent publishing refers to an increasingly popular form of self-publishing.  Rather than working with a vanity or subsidy press, the author incorporates as his or her own company, or small press, and bears the entire cost of publication, sub-contracting all associated services (copy-editing, layout design, cover design, indexing, printing, distribution, etc.).  This can be more expensive and labor-intensive proposition on the front end, but it also allows the author to maintain more control, as well as all the rights and a substantial amount more of the sales proceeds on the back end. Independently self-published books are also less stigmatized in the industry than those published by vanity or subsidy presses, as it is assumed that the cost and labor involved in the process has necessitated the author going to some lengths to ensure quality.

You may notice that this is the only form of self-publishing we’ve explored with more pros than cons…

Pros:
• Author retains control over entire publishing process
• Process from start of writing to books on bookshelves can be accomplished in half the time of commercial publishing
• All rights remain with author, completed books are author’s property, and author keeps all net sales proceeds
• Because every aspect of process can be put out to bid, can be more cost effective than vanity or subsidy publishing, and can result in a much higher-quality product
• Authors can – and should – create a publishing company name that will signal the fact that this is an independent publishing endeavor, or small press, as opposed to vanity publishing.
• Self-published books done well and/or that sell a large number of copies (5,000 or more in first year) often get picked up for resale by commercial publishers or literary agents

Cons:
• Authors undertake entire cost and labor of publication themselves, including all marketing, distribution, storage, etc.
• Can be more expensive and more labor-intensive, especially at the front end
• Works best for particular kinds of projects, such as niche non-fiction. Can be more challenging with fiction and children’s books.

 

Writing Courses

Just Write for Kids

Just Write for Kids will teach you the fundamental aspects of writing for preschoolers and elementary school-aged children.
Learn More

Editor-in-a-Box

This expanded and refined toolkit walks you through a complete picture book revision process.
Learn More

Latest from the Kid Compass Blog

Why the Publishing Process Takes So Long

Why the Publishing Process Takes So Long

One of the biggest surprises for debut authors is discovering how slooooooowly traditional publishing moves. Writers often imagine that once a manuscript sells, publication quickly follows. In reality, most traditionally…
Read more
How Much Creative Control Do Authors Really Have?

How Much Creative Control Do Authors Really Have?

Aspiring authors are often nervous about the possibility of losing creative control once they enter the publishing world. Will editors change everything? Will illustrators change the vision? Will publishers alter…
Read more
What Makes a Children’s Book Enduring?

What Makes a Children’s Book Enduring?

Publishing professionals often distinguish between books that are “marketable” and books that are “lasting.” The two are not always the same thing. A marketable book usually has a strong hook…
Read more
How Writers Find the Right Agent

How Writers Find the Right Agent

Writers often imagine that securing an agent is like winning a golden ticket — one magical “yes” that changes everything overnight. In reality, finding the right literary agent is usually…
Read more

Subscribe to the Kidlit Compass Newsletter